Write your own comment here (in english please)
This zone is only to post comment, not to ask for CD downloading, copying or trading ! Each comment can be possibly edited or deleted to ensure it is suitable for public presentation.
Should the tracklist reflect the use of other previous composers' themes? I'm sure there's lots of composers from 1 2 and 3 whose themes were adapted in this score. Should they get a (parentheses) credit as well? That's why his name is in parentheses right? because theyre using his themes?
Anyone knows if Hans gonna make soundtrack for potc 5??
No he is not... Let's hope Geoff does it... :)
I can't imagine a Pirates movie without Badelt/Zimmer's music themes. At least, they bring one of POTC old collaborations (RCP). My bet is for Balfe, Zanelli, Morris or Jackman.
Zanelli was in RCP, and his influence is all over the previous scores. He had alot to do on the first one.
Hybrid, wasn't Geoff already confirmed? I thought I read it somewhere a while ago but can't remember exactly :-p
I've been following the production of this film on the net and I got this vibe that it might be troubled production with lots of hiatus and push backs and changes. Hope this is not carried over to the score.
Geoff is in talks with production for quite some time. It's too early to say anything officially.
I really hope they give the gig to someone who was involved in the previous scores, Geoff or Henry would be great. The score should feel like it is continuing a series.
They certainly have no shortage of people who have already worked on the series! They could make up to a Pirates 20 and never use the same guy twice and still keep it within the family...lol
It has some nice new material contrary to what that abomination of an album release would like us to believe
dont know why my message was removed but can you leak spiderman 2 as well?
btw I could have sworn that
'Aboard The Queen Anne's Revenge Alternate' does play in the movie, but that its placed in the scene before the actual aboard the QAR scene
There is music playing when jack Sparrow wakes up after all
also shouldnt some of these alternates just be called 'Inserts'?
Yeah but it was written to at the same place...
Well an insert is by definition an alternate version of a segment... ;)
Sorry Medigo but I have to disagree, of course this is nice to have for "completeness" sake, but unlike The Lone Ranger which has some great little gems, this is *still* not a great score.
There's some highlights like the Mermaid scene stuff, but I'm amazed that a cue as terrible as "Carriage Chase" was even recorded. With the full orchestra it actually sounds worse as the awkward transitions, weird stilted tempo change and then the utterly anonymous and generic ending are more apparent.
well I didnt say all the tracks were good but I appreciate all the new spanish material and versions of the mermaid theme
even if the scenes they went with were ugh
An insert is not necessarily an alternate.
The Mermaid theme (and the attack music) is definitely very very good I'll grant you that. And you can hear glimpses of what they probably wanted to do with the Spanish stuff.
I would've loved to be have been there when they were recording "Blackbeard's Demise V2", they must've been laughing their asses off!